First Amendment topicsAbout the First Amendment
News Story
 
print this   Print

Minn. minister tests prohibition on political preaching

By The Associated Press
06.14.08

MINNEAPOLIS — A minister in far northern Minnesota is testing the prohibition on political preaching.

The Rev. Gus Booth of Warroad Community Church is a delegate to this year’s Republican National Convention. He gave a sermon last month urging followers to oppose Democratic presidential hopefuls Barack Obama and Hillary Rodham Clinton.

Booth alerted Americans United for Separation of Church and State to his sermon. He advised the group, which defends church-state separation, that he’s challenging federal prohibitions on political advocacy from the pulpit.

Americans United asked the Internal Revenue Service this week to investigate whether the evangelical church, which has about 150 followers, had violated its nonprofit, tax-exempt status with Booth’s sermon.

Booth, 34, told the Star Tribune his constitutional right to free expression supersedes tax law, “and the Bible has been around longer than either.”

But the Rev. Barry W. Lynn, executive director of Americans United, said the granting of a tax exemption “is not a right, it’s a privilege” that comes with restrictions.

An IRS representative declined to comment to the newspaper June 11, saying federal law prohibits disclosing information about individual taxpayers.

Booth was picked as a GOP national delegate during the 7th Congressional District convention in April, about a month before he gave his sermon. The pastor said he originally supported former Arkansas Gov. Mike Huckabee, an ordained Baptist minister who had sought the Republican nomination, but will support the presumptive GOP nominee, Sen. John McCain of Arizona.

Booth said he hasn’t calculated what losing the church’s tax-exempt status would cost it.

“If we lost it, then so be it,” he said.

Prohibitions against leaders of tax-exempt churches preaching from the pulpit in support of a candidate have been in effect since 1954, and prohibitions against preaching in opposition to a candidate have been law since 1987.

“The IRS has seen a growth in the number and variety of allegations of such behavior by [churches and other charities] during election cycles,” the agency said. In 2004 the IRS intensified efforts to enforce tax-exempt requirements and found that religious leaders used the pulpit to endorse or oppose a candidate 12 times.

The agency said it did not recommend revoking the tax-exempt status of any of the clergy’s churches, but instead issued written warnings or assessed an excise tax.

The IRS did not identify the dozen churches.

In 2006, complaints were filed against Mac Hammond of the Living Word Christian Center in Brooklyn Park for endorsing then-candidate Michele Bachmann, now a U.S. House member, from the church’s pulpit. Hammond later acknowledged that he’d made a mistake.

“To be honest with you, with a little bit of the fallout relative to Michele Bachmann, we’re taking a little bit more careful road,” said the Rev. Brian Sullivan, the church spokesman. “I don’t think we crossed the line, but it raised concerns and suspicions.”

GOP convention spokesman Matt Burns did not respond to an e-mail message from the Associated Press in time for this story.


Update
IRS halts inquiry into Minn. church
Pastor, who was under investigation for preaching politics from pulpit, says he's disappointed because he'd rather fight it out in court. 07.30.09

Related

Religion and politics Q&A

A closer look at federal restrictions that limit political activities by churches and other nonprofits. 10.18.04

IRS finds churches, charities overstep into politics

According to agency, nearly three out of four nonprofits suspected of having violated restraints on political activity in 2004 election actually did so. 03.02.06

Senator questions IRS inquiry of church over Obama speech
Joe Lieberman calls probe of denomination 'especially troubling' because agency hasn't given churches adequate guidance about what's allowed. 03.21.08

Pastor who endorsed Huckabee says he's been cleared by IRS
Wiley Drake had written press release on church letterhead asking all Southern Baptists to get behind candidate. 05.22.08

Ministers challenge group's pulpit-politicking plan
Coalition files complaint with IRS to stop Alliance Defense Fund from encouraging pastors to take political sides. 09.08.08

Pastors test ban on pulpit politicking
Thirty-three ministers in 22 states were to give sermons endorsing or opposing political candidates yesterday in effort to spark legal fight over IRS tax-exemption rules. 09.29.08

IRS to churches: Watch what you preach
By Charles C. Haynes Conflicts over churches' political role have heated up again for this election cycle. 10.01.06

Pastors, politics and the wink-wink rule
By Charles C. Haynes IRS line-drawing on pulpit-politicking seems like confused attempt to make a distinction without a difference. 06.08.08

How would Jesus vote?
By Charles C. Haynes As pastors challenge IRS rule against political endorsements from the pulpit, it may be that whether a sermon is too political should be decided by worshipers, not Washington. 10.12.08

Tax exemptions

News summary page
View the latest news stories throughout the First Amendment Center Online.



Last system update: Thursday, September 9, 2010 | 06:44:25
 SEARCH  MORE
About this site
About the First Amendment
About the First Amendment Center
How to contribute
Video/RSS/podcasts
First Amendment programs
State of the First Amendment
reports

Religious liberty in public schools
First Reports
Supreme Court
Columnists
Experts
First Amendment publications
1 for All
First Amendment Center history
Glossary
Freedom Sings™
Events
Congressional Research Service reports
Guest editorials
The First Amendment
Library

Lesson plans
freedomforum.org
Newseum
Contact us
Privacy statement
Related links